An intermittent no-start where dashboard lights remain normal

Safety-critical vehicle advice should be treated as general discussion; use qualified repair help when a fault could make a vehicle unsafe.

Occasionally I turn the key and nothing happens, although the dashboard lights stay bright. After a second attempt the engine starts normally. There's no slow cranking; it's an intermittent no-crank situation. I haven't noticed a clear pattern with temperature or how long the car sits. I'm thinking starter circuit, relay or an interlock switch rather than immediately replacing the battery. What details should I note to help a mechanic reproduce it?

  • car-repair
  • intermittent
  • start
  • dashboard
20

4 replies · Sort: Best

Best

1 reply from the original poster, shown with the conversation around them.

  1. ZS
    zeljko
    4 points

    3 replies

    Write down whether it happens in Park, Neutral, or only after you’ve driven for a while. That kind of pattern is gold for a mechanic.

    43 replies

    Write down whether it happens in Park, Neutral, or only after you’ve driven for a while. That kind of pattern is gold for a mechanic.

    4
    1. AS
      softreset4
      3 points

      Also note if the key is all the way to start or if you ever get a click. “No crank, lights normal” is useful, but a single click is a different story.

      3
    2. ling.17
      4 points

      If it’s automatic, mention whether the brake pedal feels normal too. Weird interlock stuff can be very dramatic and then disappear the moment somebody tries it in the shop.

      4

        Good point. It’s automatic, and I do usually notice it after a short stop, not after the car sits overnight. I hadn’t thought to separate th...