Games that are better with lower expectations than with hype

I played a heavily praised indie game expecting it to change my life and spent the first hour waiting for the magic. When I returned months later with no expectations, I had a lovely time. Hype had turned a perfectly good game into a test it could hardly pass. Which games did you appreciate more after the noise died down, or after you stopped expecting them to represent the future of gaming?

  • games-worth-playing
  • games
  • better
  • lower
26

5 replies · Sort: Best

Best
  1. TN
    tasdik.4
    4 points

    4 replies

    Outer Wilds was like that for me. Everyone talked about it as if it had to rewire my brain, and once I stopped trying to have a revelation,...

    44 replies

    Outer Wilds was like that for me. Everyone talked about it as if it had to rewire my brain, and once I stopped trying to have a revelation, I just enjoyed the exploration and the weird little discoveries.

    4
    1. BH
      bruno96
      3 points

      I had the same thing with Celeste. The hype made me think every minute had to be profound, but it was better when I just took it as a hard, thoughtful platformer with a lot of heart.

      3
    2. RJ
      juhlin-r
      4 points

      Disco Elysium for me. I bounced off the giant reputation around it, then came back later and let it be a strange detective game instead of some cultural event.

      4

        That’s funny, because I had the opposite reaction to one of the big indie darlings. I liked it more when I expected less, but I still think...