Choosing pot size after removing compacted nursery soil

I removed a thick plug of compacted nursery mix from a new plant and discovered more roots than expected. The root mass fits its old pot once loosened, but a few thick roots circle the bottom. I'm undecided about going up a pot size right away: too large could leave wet soil around the roots, too small means repotting again soon. How do you judge size after teasing out nursery soil without overpotting?

  • houseplants
  • choosing
  • size
  • removing
35

4 replies · Sort: Best

Best
  1. AP
    azad_75
    4 points

    3 replies

    I usually go one size up at most after I’ve teased out a nursery plug. If the root ball suddenly shrinks a lot after loosening, I’d still st...

    43 replies

    I usually go one size up at most after I’ve teased out a nursery plug. If the root ball suddenly shrinks a lot after loosening, I’d still stay closer to the original pot than the “new” root volume makes you think. The circling roots are worth guiding outward, not just burying in a huge pot.

    4
    1. AM
      greenthumb39
      3 points

      That’s pretty much what I do too. I got burned once by jumping to a pot that looked “right” after I cleaned off the peat, and the mix stayed wet forever.

      3
    2. SM
      greenthumb_susan
      4 points

      I’m a little more cautious than that and sometimes keep the same pot if the roots aren’t packed hard anymore. It depends on the plant, though. My pothos didn’t mind a small step up, but a fern sulked in a bigger pot for weeks.

      4

        The fern part makes sense to me. I think the main question is whether the root mass can hold together after watering. If it can’t, the extra...