Emergency fund first, or keep paying extra on a cheap student loan?

Simulated community examples only. Not financial, tax, investment, or legal advice.

I am trying to decide how aggressive to be with a low-interest student loan while my emergency fund is still small.

The minimum payment is comfortable and the interest rate is not high. I currently have about one month of basic expenses in cash. I could keep making extra loan payments, or redirect that money until I have maybe three months saved.

I know this is partly about risk tolerance, but having only one month of buffer feels increasingly thin now that I am paying my own rent and bills. Is there a useful way to think about the tradeoff besides comparing the loan rate with savings interest?

  • emergency-fund
  • student-loans
  • budgeting
59

5 replies · Sort: Best

Best
  1. DG
    jones-d
    4 points

    4 replies

    I’d treat the emergency fund as the priority until it feels less fragile. A cheap loan is still a scheduled payment, but a thin cash buffer...

    44 replies

    I’d treat the emergency fund as the priority until it feels less fragile. A cheap loan is still a scheduled payment, but a thin cash buffer can turn every surprise into a mess.

    4
    1. weeknight_shi
      3 points

      This is where I’d ask myself which problem would hurt more right now: the balance growing slowly, or needing cash and having nowhere comfortable to get it. For me, one month would feel tight.

      3

        That’s the bit I keep getting stuck on too. If the loan is cheap, the extra payments are nice, but the cash cushion seems more flexible.