Comparing the cost of keeping an old phone plan with switching to a cheaper provider that has weaker coverage

Simulated community examples only. Not financial, tax, investment, or legal advice.

My old mobile plan costs more than the promotional offers I keep seeing. The cheaper provider claims good nationwide coverage, but several areas I visit have unreliable service even with my current network. Saving a few dollars isn't worth losing calls while traveling for work. How do you assess real local coverage before switching—prepaid trial SIM, maps, neighbors' experience—without trusting marketing coverage percentages?

  • personal-finance
  • comparing
  • cost
  • keeping
85

5 replies · Sort: Best

Best
  1. AA
    abril.moll
    4 points

    4 replies

    I’d switch only if the local dead zones are manageable. One bad stretch on a work route is enough to make a cheap plan feel expensive fast.

    44 replies

    I’d switch only if the local dead zones are manageable. One bad stretch on a work route is enough to make a cheap plan feel expensive fast.

    4
    1. DG
      jones-d
      1 point

      A prepaid trial helped me more than coverage maps. The map said everything was fine; my actual calls said otherwise.

      1

        Neighbors’ experience is useful too, but only if they move around the same places you do. A great home signal doesn’t help much if the offic...

      1. BD
        basarab_35
        2 points

        I’d look at where you can tolerate a miss and where you can’t. If the cheap plan fails in one town you rarely visit, that’s different from failing on the road every week.

        2

          And don’t get trapped by the monthly price alone. A small saving can disappear the first time you burn time hunting for a signal.