Recovering highlight detail in bright skies without making shadows unnatural

I shot a landscape with a bright clouded sky over a shaded street. Pulling the highlights down brings back cloud texture, but lifting the shadows enough to see the buildings makes the whole image flat and oddly gray. It looked much more contrasty in person. I'm editing a RAW file, so there is some room to work, but I'm starting to think I should leave parts of the street dark. Where do you draw the line between recovering detail and destroying the light that made the scene interesting?

  • photography
  • recovering
  • highlight
  • detail
57

5 replies · Sort: Best

Best

1 reply from the original poster, shown with the conversation around them.

  1. RL
    ralph_8
    4 points

    1 reply

    One thing I check is whether the street was actually dark in person or just dark on camera. If it looked dramatic to the eye, I think the im...

    41 reply

    One thing I check is whether the street was actually dark in person or just dark on camera. If it looked dramatic to the eye, I think the image can keep some of that darkness instead of forcing a perfectly balanced look.

    4
    1. SS
      silvia.safitriOP
      1 point

      That’s where I’m stuck too. The scene felt punchy in real life, but once I start recovering shadow detail it gets polite and weird.

      1